Pin it
This hearty Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookie recipe transforms the beloved breakfast pastry into a soft, cake-like cookie with a gooey brown sugar-cinnamon filling. Each bite delivers that nostalgic pop tart flavor but in a more sophisticated, homemade cookie form that will delight both kids and adults.
I first made these cookies during a rainy weekend when my niece was visiting. She declared them better than actual pop tarts and now requests them every time she stays over. The way her face lights up when she bites into that cinnamon center makes all the effort worthwhile.
Ingredients
- Unsalted butter: provides richness and helps create that tender texture. Make sure it's properly softened but still cool to touch for best results
- Light brown sugar: delivers caramel notes that make these cookies special. I recommend using fresh brown sugar that's still soft
- Cake flour: creates an exceptionally tender crumb. The lower protein content is key to achieving that perfect texture
- Cornstarch: works alongside cake flour to produce a soft bakery style cookie that stays tender for days
- Cinnamon: is the star spice that brings warmth to both filling and glaze. Use fresh high quality cinnamon for the best flavor impact
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Make the Cookie Dough:
- Beat butter and sugars for a full 2-3 minutes until light and fluffy. This incorporates air for better texture. Add eggs and vanilla, mixing thoroughly. The mixture should look almost mousse-like at this stage. Whisk dry ingredients separately then incorporate gradually. The dough will be soft but not sticky. Chill for one hour minimum. This step is non-negotiable for proper cookie structure.
- Prepare the Brown Sugar Filling:
- Combine softened butter, packed brown sugar, cinnamon and cake flour until completely smooth. The filling should be soft but moldable. If it feels too wet, add a touch more flour. If too dry, add a tiny bit more butter. Roll into small balls about the size of a large marble. This filling is what makes these cookies truly special.
- Assemble the Cookies:
- Take a quarter cup of chilled dough and split in half. Create a depression in one half, nestle the filling ball inside, then cap with the remaining dough half. Seal edges completely and roll into a ball. Work quickly so the dough stays cool. Any gaps will allow filling to leak during baking. Place on prepared baking sheets with ample spacing.
- Bake to Perfection:
- Bake in a preheated 350°F oven until just set. The tops should be barely golden and still look slightly underdone in the center. This ensures cookies remain soft after cooling. Watch carefully during the final minutes as overbaking will result in dry cookies. Let cool on the pan for five minutes before transferring to a cooling rack.
- Create the Signature Glaze:
- Whisk powdered sugar, cinnamon, melted butter and milk until completely smooth. The consistency should be pourable but thick enough to set properly. Drizzle or spread over completely cooled cookies. Allow glaze to set for about 15 minutes before serving or storing. This gives cookies their authentic pop tart appearance.
Pin it
The brown sugar filling is truly what makes these cookies exceptional. I once tried to shortcut by using plain cinnamon sugar and they were good but not great. That rich molasses note from brown sugar combined with butter creates a filling that stays soft even after baking, just like the inside of a real pop tart.
Storage Success
These cookies maintain their texture remarkably well for several days when stored properly. Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature, separating layers with parchment paper to prevent sticking. For longer storage, refrigerate for up to a week, though I find the texture is best within the first three days. Let chilled cookies come to room temperature before serving for the best flavor experience.
Make-Ahead Magic
This recipe works wonderfully for planning ahead. Prepare the cookie dough and filling up to two days before baking and keep refrigerated. For longer storage, freeze the assembled unbaked cookies on a sheet pan until solid, then transfer to freezer bags for up to three months. Bake directly from frozen, adding just a minute or two to the baking time. The icing can also be prepared ahead and stored in the refrigerator for up to a week just bring to room temperature before using.
Pin it
Perfect Pairing Suggestions
Serve these cookies slightly warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream for an elevated dessert. They pair beautifully with a cup of coffee or chai tea in the afternoon. For a fun brunch offering, arrange them on a platter alongside actual pop tarts for a playful comparison. During the holidays, these make wonderful additions to cookie exchanges since they stand out from traditional offerings while still feeling familiar and comforting.
The Perfect Frosting Finish
The cinnamon glaze is what truly makes these cookies reminiscent of classic brown sugar pop tarts. The key is achieving the right consistency not too thin or it will run off, but not too thick or it will sit in a blob. I like to place the cookies on a wire rack with parchment underneath before glazing. This allows excess to drip off while creating that perfect pop tart appearance. For a festive twist, add sprinkles while the glaze is still wet during holiday season.
A Childhood Throwback
These cookies create an immediate nostalgic connection. The flavor profile perfectly captures those brown sugar cinnamon pop tarts many of us enjoyed as children, but elevates them with real ingredients and better texture. I find they bridge generations at gatherings older folks appreciate the craftsmanship while younger ones connect with the familiar flavor. This recipe proves that sometimes reimagining a classic can create something even better than the original.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How do I ensure the cookies stay soft?
Using cake flour and cornstarch creates a tender crumb, and chilling the dough prevents spreading while baking.
- → What is the best way to seal the filling inside the cookie?
Ensure you pinch the seams tightly and roll the dough into a ball to fully enclose the cinnamon filling.
- → Can I make these cookies ahead of time?
Yes! Prep the dough and filling, then assemble and freeze for later baking. You can also freeze baked cookies without glaze.
- → Can I substitute cake flour with all-purpose flour?
Yes, but the texture will be slightly less tender. Use the same measurement for all-purpose flour.
- → How do I prevent the glaze from running off the cookies?
Ensure the cookies are completely cool before drizzling the glaze, and adjust the glaze consistency by adding more milk or powdered sugar as needed.