Pin it
This butterscotch heaven pie transforms simple ingredients into an indulgent dessert that balances creamy butterscotch filling with a crisp graham cracker crust. The combination creates a nostalgic treat that never fails to impress guests while being surprisingly easy to prepare.
I first made this pie for my daughter's birthday when she requested something different than cake. The look on her face when she took that first bite has made this our special occasion tradition ever since.
Ingredients
- Graham Cracker Crumbs: form the perfect crunchy foundation that complements the creamy filling
- Unsalted Butter: binds the crust together and adds richness look for European style for extra flavor
- Butterscotch Pudding Mix: creates that classic flavor without hours of cooking
- Whole Milk: provides richness that light milk simply cannot match
- Heavy Cream: adds luxurious texture to both filling and topping
- Cream Cheese: brings tangy depth that balances the sweetness
- Brown Sugar: enhances the caramel notes use dark brown for more intensity
- Vanilla Extract: rounds out the flavors choose pure not imitation for best results
- Caramel Sauce: creates that final drizzle of decadence homemade elevates it further
How To Make Butterscotch Heaven Pie
- Prepare the Crust:
- Combine graham cracker crumbs with sugar and melted butter until every crumb is moistened. The mixture should hold together when pressed between your fingers without being overly greasy. Press firmly into your pie dish using the bottom of a measuring cup to create an even layer with slightly built up sides. Bake just until fragrant and barely golden around the edges.
- Create the Filling:
- Beat room temperature cream cheese until absolutely smooth with no lumps whatsoever. This creates the silky base for your filling. Gradually incorporate the pudding mix, milk, cream, brown sugar and vanilla, mixing constantly to prevent any lumps from forming. Continue beating until the mixture thickens noticeably and holds soft peaks when the beater is lifted.
- Assemble with Care:
- Pour your filling into the completely cooled crust, working slowly from the center outward. Use an offset spatula to create a smooth, slightly domed surface. Tap the pie dish gently on the counter to release any air bubbles that might be trapped within the filling.
- Perfect the Presentation:
- Apply the whipped topping in decorative swirls or peaks, leaving a small border of filling visible around the edge. When drizzling the caramel, use a back and forth motion with your wrist to create artistic patterns rather than simply pouring it in one spot.
Pin it
The butterscotch pudding mix is truly the secret weapon in this recipe. While I typically prefer making everything from scratch, this shortcut ingredient creates that perfect nostalgic butterscotch flavor that reminds me of my grandmother's kitchen. I remember her teaching me to always chill cream pies properly so they set up perfectly.
Make It Your Own
This pie welcomes creative variations that maintain its creamy essence while allowing for personal touches. Try folding chopped toffee bits into the filling before chilling for delightful crunchy surprises in each bite. For chocolate lovers, drizzle chocolate sauce alongside the caramel or sprinkle chocolate shavings over the top.
Storage Solutions
This butterscotch heaven pie maintains its quality in the refrigerator for up to 4 days when properly covered. For best results, wait to add the whipped topping and caramel drizzle until just before serving if planning to store longer than 24 hours. The crust will stay crispest when the pie is stored in a container that doesn't touch the topping.
Serving Suggestions
Transform this pie into an impressive dessert bar by cutting into smaller squares and serving alongside coffee or tea. For special occasions, warm the caramel sauce slightly before drizzling and add a sprinkle of flaky sea salt to elevate the flavor profile. A scoop of vanilla ice cream alongside creates a memorable à la mode experience.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use a store-bought crust?
Yes, a pre-made graham cracker crust works perfectly if you want to save prep time.
- → Can I substitute Cool Whip for whipped cream?
Absolutely, both Cool Whip and freshly whipped cream work well as toppings for this dessert.
- → How long should the pie chill before serving?
Refrigerate the pie for at least 3 hours, or preferably overnight, to ensure it sets properly.
- → Can I make the caramel sauce at home?
Yes, homemade caramel sauce is a delicious alternative to store-bought, and it's easy to prepare using sugar, butter, and cream.
- → Is there an alternative to butterscotch pudding mix?
If you can’t find butterscotch pudding mix, you can experiment with vanilla pudding and add butterscotch extract or additional brown sugar for flavor.