Banana Pudding Brownies

Imagine biting into a decadent brownie that captures all the nostalgic flavors of classic banana pudding. These Banana Pudding Brownies combine the fudgy texture of a perfect brownie with the creamy comfort of homemade vanilla pudding, ripe bananas, and those beloved vanilla wafer cookies. Every time I make these, the aroma of vanilla and caramelized bananas fills my kitchen, bringing back memories of summer afternoons enjoying banana pudding at my grandmother's house.

Last weekend, I brought these to a family gathering, and my cousin's kids, who usually avoid anything with fruit, devoured them. The secret? The bananas create an incredibly moist brownie while the vanilla pudding swirl adds that creamy element everyone loves.

Essential Ingredients and Selection Tips

• Bananas - Look for ones with plenty of brown spots for the best flavor and natural sweetness. I've found that bananas that are almost too ripe for eating are perfect for baking
• Vanilla Wafer Cookies - Choose fresh, crisp cookies. The staleness becomes noticeable in the final product. I always buy an extra box because snacking while baking is inevitable
• Brown Sugar - Light or dark both work beautifully, but dark brown sugar adds extra depth. Store with a piece of bread to prevent hardening
• Butter - Use unsalted butter to control the salt content. Room temperature butter creates the smoothest pudding
• Vanilla Extract - Pure vanilla extract makes a noticeable difference in both the pudding and brownie base

Years of baking have taught me that measuring the mashed bananas precisely is crucial - too much can make the brownies too cake-like, while too little loses that signature banana pudding flavor.

Detailed Cooking Instructions

1. Pudding Preparation

Start with the vanilla pudding base - warm your milk in a heavy-bottomed saucepan over medium heat. In a separate bowl, whisk together sugar, flour, and egg yolk until pale. The key is gradually tempering the hot milk into this mixture while whisking constantly - I learned through experience that rushing this step can lead to scrambled eggs. Return everything to the pan and cook until it thickens enough to coat the back of a spoon, about 5-7 minutes of constant stirring.

2. Brownie Base Creation

While the pudding cools, prepare your brownie batter. Melt butter until just liquid - you want it warm, not hot. Mix with both sugars until well combined. This is where the magic starts - add your perfectly ripe mashed bananas and watch how they transform the batter's texture. Whisk in the egg yolk and vanilla until the mixture becomes glossy and smooth.

3. Dry Ingredient Integration

Sift flour, baking powder, and salt together - this extra step prevents lumps and ensures even distribution. Fold these dry ingredients into your wet mixture with gentle strokes, stopping just when the last flour streak disappears. Overmixing is the enemy of fudgy brownies.

4. Layering Process

Here's where we build those beautiful layers. Spread half your brownie batter in the prepared pan - I use the back of a spoon to ensure even distribution. Press a layer of vanilla wafers into the batter, creating a foundation for that classic banana pudding texture.

5. Final Assembly

Dollop remaining brownie batter and cooled pudding in alternating spoonfuls. Create swirls using a knife or skewer - I like to make figure-eight patterns for the most attractive marbling effect.

Pin it

During recipe testing, my daughter pointed out that adding an extra layer of crushed wafers on top before baking creates an amazing textural contrast. She was absolutely right - sometimes the best tips come from unexpected sources.

Pin it

Perfect Temperature Control

Your oven temperature accuracy is crucial here. I keep an oven thermometer inside to ensure it's truly at 350°F. The center should still be slightly jiggly when you remove the pan - it will set as it cools.

Achieving the Right Texture

The toothpick test works differently for these brownies because of the pudding swirl. Look for moist crumbs from the brownie portions, while pudding areas will be creamy.

Storage Wisdom

These brownies actually taste better the next day, after the flavors have had time to meld. Store them in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 3 days.

Chef's Essential Tips

• Line your pan with parchment paper, leaving overhang for easy removal. Trust me, trying to get the first brownie out of an unlined pan is heartbreaking
• Room temperature eggs blend more smoothly into the pudding mixture. I place mine in warm water for 5 minutes if I forget to take them out early
• When swirling, less is more - too much mixing will blur the distinct pudding and brownie layers

Pin it

Final Thoughts

These Banana Pudding Brownies represent the best of both worlds - the fudgy decadence of brownies and the comforting charm of banana pudding. They've become my go-to recipe for potlucks and family gatherings, not just because they're delicious, but because they spark joy and nostalgia in everyone who tries them. Each batch I make gets a little better as I learn new tricks, but the basic magic of this combination never fails to impress.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Why measure flour properly?

Incorrect measuring leads to dry brownies - use spoon-level method or scale

→ Can I use store-bought pudding?

Homemade works best but instant pudding can work in a pinch

→ How ripe should bananas be?

Use very ripe, spotted bananas for best flavor

→ Can I freeze these?

Yes, freeze up to 1 month in airtight container

→ Why aren't my brownies fudgy?

Too much flour is usually the culprit - measure carefully